fix: junction limits are honest at the boundaries (#331)

Six normative cuts, both mirrors symmetric (spec revision 3):

- §2.1 node keys quantise to 1e-7 with the repository's canonicalisation
  formula (sign·floor(|v|·1e7+0.5)/1e7, -0 normalised) — toFixed(6) keys
  split one node into two on floating debris and produced two false П4
  refusals on a legitimate resize (reproduced: -1e-8 vs 0). Node pairs
  within 2e-7 of each other (raw coordinates) are ONE node, and the
  node-to-wall incidence uses the same quantum.
- §2.2 a ~0° wedge IS a violation: two rays leaving a node the same way are
  a duplicated or overlaid wall (a butt joint yields 180°, never 0°) — the
  worst degenerate case was invisible while 0.5° was refused.
- §2.3/§2.4 the wall run is an iterative edge walk over the collinear
  component: no recursion (10 000 atoms answered, not RangeError), no
  silently dropped fork (the old .find lost every branch but the first),
  O(E) by construction, and collinearity is measured against the BASE
  segment's axis so an arc of 0.9°-per-atom pieces cannot pose as one wall.
- §2.5 an exception while judging the CANDIDATE refuses the write with the
  junction.limit_check_failed toast (fail-closed, as the #278 guard); the
  baseline branch stays fail-open by design and the smoke proves the
  asymmetry by breaking only the second call of the deterministic pair.
- §2.6 the python mirror narrows its except on the candidate side only:
  a genuine migration bug (TypeError) surfaces as an honest WS error, while
  a previous-side bug keeps the wide "no baseline" fallback — the two AC6
  cases pin the asymmetry so swapped sides turn a unit red.

Parity fixtures gain the new boundary classes (debris node, duplicate wall,
collinear fork); four new mutants pin the filter, the key precision, the
dropped branch and the fail-open hole.

Issue: #331
User-Visible: yes
This commit is contained in:
Codex
2026-08-28 04:39:46 +03:00
parent c231602a2b
commit 58f3acbbde
17 changed files with 582 additions and 217 deletions
File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long
+66 -31
View File
@@ -18,7 +18,13 @@ from __future__ import annotations
import math
from .wall_segment_model import WALL_SEGMENT_MODEL_VERSION, commit_wall_segment_model
import logging
from .wall_segment_model import (
WALL_SEGMENT_MODEL_VERSION, WallSegmentMigrationError, commit_wall_segment_model,
)
_LOGGER = logging.getLogger(__name__)
MIN_JUNCTION_ANGLE_DEG = 15.0
MAX_JUNCTION_VALENCE = 6
@@ -28,8 +34,10 @@ MIN_NODE_DISTANCE_CM = 5.0
GRID_STEP_N = 1 / 240
_EPS = 1e-9
# Below this a node is ON the wall (T-joint), not near it.
_INCIDENT_EPS = 1e-9
# #331 §2.1: below this two points are ONE node / a node is ON the wall —
# floating debris of pre-canonicalisation arithmetic, not a near miss.
_INCIDENT_EPS = 2e-7
_KEY_FACTOR = 1e7
class JunctionLimitError(ValueError):
@@ -58,8 +66,21 @@ def _finite_point(point: object) -> bool:
)
def _quantize_key_coord(value: float) -> float:
"""#331 §2.1: the canonicalisation formula — sign*floor(|v|*f+0.5)/f.
Native round() is banker's rounding and parts ways with JS Math-style
rounding on .5 ticks; coordinate canonicalisation already encodes this
parity lesson, and node keys must follow it. -0 normalises to 0.
"""
rounded = math.copysign(
math.floor(abs(value) * _KEY_FACTOR + 0.5), value,
) / _KEY_FACTOR
return 0.0 if rounded == 0 else rounded
def _key(point) -> str:
return f"{point[0]:.6f},{point[1]:.6f}"
return f"{_quantize_key_coord(point[0])},{_quantize_key_coord(point[1])}"
def _length(a, b) -> float:
@@ -127,8 +148,9 @@ def check_nodes(segments: list[dict]) -> list[tuple[str, str, float, float]]:
if index == len(ordered) - 1:
delta += math.pi * 2
degrees = (delta * 180) / math.pi
# Collinear rays of one straight wall are a 180° pair, not a wedge.
if _EPS < degrees < smallest:
# #331 §2.2: a ~0° delta IS a violation — same-direction rays are
# a duplicated or overlaid wall (a butt joint yields 180°, not 0°).
if degrees < smallest:
smallest = degrees
if smallest < MIN_JUNCTION_ANGLE_DEG - 1e-9:
violations.append(("angle", node, smallest, MIN_JUNCTION_ANGLE_DEG))
@@ -161,38 +183,34 @@ def collinear_run_length_units(
) -> float:
"""Length of the WALL a segment belongs to, not of the atom.
Atomisation at a thickness step leaves pieces nobody drew — where a 30 cm
wall meets a 20 cm one, a (30−20)/2 = 5 cm piece continues the same wall.
They are collinear continuations at the same thickness, so П3 measures the
maximal collinear chain through the segment's nodes.
#331 §2.3/§2.4: an iterative edge walk over the collinear component — no
recursion (a 10 000-atom chain must answer, not overflow), no
combinatorial DFS (every atom joins at most once, O(E)), no silently
dropped fork. Collinearity is measured against the BASE segment's axis,
so an arc of small per-atom turns cannot pose as one straight wall.
#330 §4.3: building the index per SEGMENT made П3 quadratic (285 ms on
576 atoms); the per-check caller builds it once and passes it in.
#330 §4.3: the per-check caller builds the node index once.
"""
by_node = by_node_index if by_node_index is not None else _build_node_index(segments)
visited = [segment]
visited = {id(segment)}
total = _length(segment["a"], segment["b"])
def walk(current: dict, node: str) -> None:
nonlocal total
for candidate in by_node.get(node, []):
if any(candidate is seen for seen in visited):
frontier = [segment["a"], segment["b"]]
base_cm = float(segment.get("cm") or 0)
while frontier:
node = frontier.pop()
for candidate in by_node.get(_key(node), ()):
if id(candidate) in visited:
continue
if not _collinear(candidate, current):
if not _collinear(candidate, segment):
continue
if float(candidate.get("cm") or 0) != float(current.get("cm") or 0):
if float(candidate.get("cm") or 0) != base_cm:
continue
visited.append(candidate)
visited.add(id(candidate))
total += _length(candidate["a"], candidate["b"])
walk(candidate, _key(candidate["b"])
if _key(candidate["a"]) == node else _key(candidate["a"]))
return
walk(segment, _key(segment["a"]))
walk(segment, _key(segment["b"]))
frontier.append(candidate["a"])
frontier.append(candidate["b"])
return total
def check_segment_lengths(
segments: list[dict], cell_cm: float, grid_pitch: float = GRID_STEP_N,
) -> list[tuple[str, str, float, float]]:
@@ -263,6 +281,10 @@ def check_node_distances(
if node_key >= other_key:
continue
distance = _length(point, other)
# #331 §2.1: raw debris within the incidence quantum is ONE
# node on two neighbouring keys — never a near miss.
if distance <= _INCIDENT_EPS:
continue
if distance < min_units - 1e-9:
violations.append((
"distance", f"{node_key} ↔ {other_key}",
@@ -297,7 +319,7 @@ def space_violations(space: dict) -> list[tuple[str, str, float, float]]:
]
def _migrated_spaces(config: dict | None) -> dict[str, dict]:
def _migrated_spaces(config: dict | None, *, side: str = "previous") -> dict[str, dict]:
"""Spaces of one document AFTER the wall-segment migration, by id.
The limits read `wall_segments`, so a document that predates the catalogue
@@ -325,7 +347,20 @@ def _migrated_spaces(config: dict | None) -> dict[str, dict]:
else:
try:
migrated, _ = commit_wall_segment_model(config)
except Exception: # noqa: BLE001 — see the docstring: not our verdict
except (WallSegmentMigrationError, ValueError) as error:
# The wall-model barrier owns this verdict and reports it with its
# own code; here it merely means "no catalogue to read".
_LOGGER.debug("junction limits: %s migration fell back: %s", side, error)
migrated = config
except Exception:
# #331 §2.6 (AC6): a genuine migration bug on the CANDIDATE side
# must surface as an honest WS error, not a silent "no
# violations". The PREVIOUS side keeps the wide fallback — an
# unprovable inheritance is no reason to block an unrelated write
# (the exact P1 symptom this task fixes).
if side == "candidate":
raise
_LOGGER.debug("junction limits: previous-side migration bug swallowed by design")
migrated = config
return {
str(space.get("id")): space
@@ -371,7 +406,7 @@ def validate_junction_limits(
old_counts = baseline_counts
else:
old_counts = space_violation_counts(_migrated_spaces(previous))
new_spaces = _migrated_spaces(config)
new_spaces = _migrated_spaces(config, side="candidate")
candidate_counts: dict[str, dict[str, int]] = {}
for space_id, space in new_spaces.items():
# A brand-new space has nothing to inherit from — but neither is a