Reviewed by Claude in CODE-REVIEW-378-r2 against the complete Linux candidate. Exactly the new 42 percent value-face frame is accepted; 142 existing baselines retain their reviewed hashes.
Issue: #378
User-Visible: no
Release: v1.69.0-beta.5
Baseline-Reviewed: https://github.com/Matysh/houseplan-card/actions/runs/33271690654
(а) title: null gets the same compact frame as title: '' — YAML 'title:'
with no value parses as null, the owner's decision makes them synonyms.
(б) the guides state that room labels are inert in the Background editor.
(г) furniture strokes skip the flat-camera compensation in the labs iso
projection, tracking ordinary decor there.
(д) TESTING.md notes the light_pools opt-in for static room cards.
(е) the space-card dispose gate mirrors the strict === true render gate.
User-Visible: yes
Issue: #376
settings.decor_default_style (all fields optional, validated) seeds
_decorStyle once from the first config that arrives; every UI change of
the session default flows through one runtime method with a 1s debounce
and the ordinary serialized expected_rev write path. The built-in default
is stored as the absence of the key; a partial or garbage key falls back
per-field. decorStyleFromSettings/decorStyleToSettings are the single
snake_case<->camelCase conversion point.
User-Visible: yes
Issue: #377
The complete French dictionary contributed in #371 (1026 keys, zero empty
values, zero placeholder mismatches) lands as the second lazy locale on the
fr.ts + one static entry. The contributor's snapshot predated this week's
keys, so the 121 additions (device inbox #29, backdrop guard #39, junction
limits #331, lazy-editor toasts #353/#354, furniture #159) are translated
in this commit and flagged in the issue for the author's review; 21 stale
pre-#62 keys are dropped; key order follows en.json. The HA integration
translations file ships as contributed (full parity).
Wiring: loadFrench + __HOUSEPLAN_FR_RETRY_ASSET__ with the same 1/1
replacement guarantee as German; locale roles and localeRoots generalise to
(de|fr); the stale-entry fallback panel (#353) gains its French branch —
the r1 reviewer caught that this second hardcoded language list would have
silently degraded French to English on a cached entry. French profiles
(fr, fr-FR, fr-CA, fr-BE, fr-CH) select automatically.
Proofs: the registry-driven parity suite covers fr by construction
(1128/1128 keys); French analogues of both German-personal tests (product
glossary + non-translation scan with a reviewed equal-to-English
allow-list of 22 legitimate homographs); smoke_french_locale — fr-CA
profile commits French from the real bundle, one lazy chunk per page,
initial graph free of fr; smoke_entry_stale gains the French run; a
registry mutant drops the fr entry and is killed by the smoke. Initial
view: +0.5 KB (registry entry + fallback branch); the 23 KB dictionary is
lazy.
Issue: #371
User-Visible: yes
The r2 reviewer proved two real exits leaked the window keydown/keyup
listeners of the furniture preview — Escape (the card closes the palette
by direct assignment, bypassing the runtime paths) and disconnectedCallback
(only _clearFurniturePreview ran). The arrow-field listener pins the whole
editor runtime and, through it, the card: the exact leak class this
disconnectedCallback already names two cases above. Both sites now call
_furnShiftDetach alongside the preview cleanup, the smoke gained the
Escape regression (re-arm attaches again, Escape closes the palette AND
brings removes level with adds), and the idempotent double detach in
_furnPlace (r2 Low) is gone.
Issue: #369
User-Visible: no
(a) documented: deleting a vacuum marker erases its server trail at once
and a re-added marker starts from scratch (VACUUM.md + both USER-GUIDEs).
(b) smoothVacPath reports dropped non-finite segments — one console warn
per call with the count — instead of hiding the whole trail silently on a
broken calibration matrix. (c) room climate (#317) now reaches legacy
markers whose exported config carries an ABSENT area key rather than an
explicit null: `== null` where the placement is decided. (d) the armed
furniture preview follows Shift without mouse movement — window
keydown/keyup listeners live exactly as long as the palette is armed,
detached at every palette teardown. (e) only the primary mouse button
places decor/furniture: a right or middle click with an armed tool is a
no-op, touch/pen untouched. (f) a device whose registry entities were ALL
deliberately disabled by the user no longer glows as an alive controller —
the #318 entityless-active rule now requires a genuinely empty roster.
(g) furniture-pack author corrected to Sergey Matyunin (Сергей Матюнин)
per the owner's decision — LICENSE.md, README.md, pack.json,
docs/FURNITURE.md, the provenance check in generate-furniture-assets and
its unit; the source archive bytes are unchanged and the README notes the
romanisation fix.
Proofs: units for (b)/(c)/(f) including the #318 regression pair; new
smoke_furniture_polish for (d)/(e) with listener add/remove counters and
both mouse buttons; five registry mutants, one per code change.
Issue: #369
User-Visible: yes
r1-M1: dismissal (Escape/scrim/Cancel) while the reduce or keep-original
flow is executing no longer races the decision — hp-close is ignored while
busy, and every flow re-checks it still owns the guard before applying, so
a force-cleared dialog can never silently install its stale result. The
smoke now drives both: hp-close during a hanging decode leaves the busy
dialog up, and a force-cleared guard ends with clean staging, no toast, no
planFile. A new registry mutant removes the busy gate and is killed.
r1-M2: the hard-dialog text takes its limit from the imported
HARD_DIMENSION instead of a literal — recalibration stays a one-file
change, as the spec promises.
r1-M3: AC8 is now proven end to end, not plausible: the smoke splices a
real EXIF APP1 (orientation 6) into a canvas-encoded 8200×4100 JPEG,
asserts the header probe reads the unrotated SOF, that the decode call
carries imageOrientation:'from-image' (captured on the hook), and that the
reduced copy comes out portrait 2048×4096. TESTING.md names the scenario.
Issue: #39
User-Visible: no
A picked raster is now classified from its HEADER BYTES ONLY before anything
heavy happens: src/backdrop-probe.ts parses PNG IHDR (+colour type/tRNS for
alpha), JPEG SOF and WebP VP8/VP8L/VP8X at fixed offsets, never using a file
field as an allocation size; hostile or truncated headers collapse to
'unknown', which warns without numbers instead of passing silently. The
thresholds live in that module as the single calibration point
(WARN_DECODED_BYTES 128 MiB ≈ 32 MP, HARD_DIMENSION 16384 — the browser
canvas cap, DOWNSCALE_TARGET_PX 4096), derived from the desktop-Chromium
matrix now committed as demo/benchmark_backdrop_decode.mjs with a
conservative tablet margin documented in the spec.
The shared pick flow (src/backdrop-pick.ts) feeds BOTH lazy runtimes — the
editor space dialog and the onboarding first-space dialog — so the guard
cannot drift between them, and nothing of it enters the eager View graph.
Warn shows the real numbers and three actions; the reduced copy decodes
EXIF-aware, keeps aspect and alpha (PNG stays PNG, opaque becomes JPEG
q0.9) and flows through the ordinary planFile → upload path. Hard has two
phases with one outcome: beyond 16384 px only Cancel; a failed or timed-out
(10 s) reduce closes with a toast, clean staging and NO silent fallback to
the original the user just declined. SVG never reaches the probe. The safe
path swaps the manual byte-loop base64 for FileReader — half the JS-heap
peak on every upload, byte-identical output (parity asserted in the smoke).
Proofs: header-table units incl. a fuzz set of hostile headers and ±1
threshold bounds; smoke_backdrop_guard on the real bundle — zero decode
calls before the choice, byte parity of keep-original, a real 6200 px
reduce to 4096 for both alpha and opaque branches, cancel-only hard
dialog, both phase-2 failures (reject and hang under the test-only timeout
override), re-pick after refusal, SVG bypass; four registry mutants
(probe-always-safe, alpha-dropped, hard-demoted, phase-2 silent fallback).
Spec anchor corrected alongside: the server plan limit is 8 MB
(MAX_PLAN_BYTES), attachments are the 50 MB path — an 8 MB JPEG is easily
80-160 MP decoded, so the client-side guard stays the primary defence.
Issue: #39
User-Visible: yes
The code-review worker published its report from a stale local snapshot and unintentionally reverted the already reviewed implementation artifacts. Restore every affected path exactly to the reviewed 84bdc7ef tree while retaining CODE-REVIEW-359-r1.md.
Issue: #359
User-Visible: no
Reviewed the Linux candidate from the full CI run. Only the new furniture placement preview frame is accepted; 141 existing baselines remain byte-identical.
Issue: #359
User-Visible: no
Release: v1.69.0-beta.2
Baseline-Reviewed: https://github.com/Matysh/houseplan-card/actions/runs/33213146088
Accept the reviewed Linux frame left pending by #20 alongside the already accepted #209 vacuum frame. The closed and partially open doors now form the visual contract for proportional Glow transmission.
Issue: #209
User-Visible: no
Release: v1.69.0-beta.2
Baseline-Reviewed: https://github.com/Matysh/houseplan-card/actions/runs/33207816479
Reviewed the Linux candidate for the deterministic current and previous vacuum routes. Only the new #209 frame is accepted; the unrelated door-hover drift was explicitly retained at its existing reviewed baseline.
Issue: #209
User-Visible: no
Release: v1.69.0-beta.2
Baseline-Reviewed: https://github.com/Matysh/houseplan-card/actions/runs/33207816479
Systematic audit after #357 ("can there be more bugs with this root
cause?"): _vacMapId was the one remaining hard stub reachable from the
eager View path. It runs inside willUpdate for every vacuum whose
integration reports live telemetry (Tasshack, XCME, Valetudo), so on a
cold tab the #337 stub threw there and the exception took the whole Lit
update cycle with it — the card froze on its very first frame. The demo
mower has no position attributes, telemetry resolved to null, and every
existing smoke (warm and cold) sailed past the branch.
The card now owns the implementation (both dependencies — _vacEntity and
vacMapIdWithFallback — were already eager); the editor runtime delegates
back to the host. The HP-1541-01 invariant (selected_map: 0 is a real map
id, nullish not truthy) moves verbatim and is pinned by the new smoke.
Hardened alongside (audit Lows): _decorShapeDown gets the same
cold-tab guard its twin _decorShapeDbl received in #337 — decor shapes
render in View and CSS pointer-events alone must not be what prevents a
throw; the _vacCalConfirm dialog renders behind the same _editorRuntime
gate as every other editor dialog instead of relying on the implicit
"only the runtime ever sets it".
smoke_cold_view_vacuum: cold tab, vacuum with vacuum_position and
selected_map: 0 — the card commits three successive telemetry frames
(willUpdate alive, not merely the first paint), map id resolves to '0',
no editor chunk requested, a decor pointerdown is a quiet no-op. A
registry mutant restores the delegation and is killed by that smoke.
Issue: #358
User-Visible: yes
Field report from the dacha: the wall switch "Гостиная основной свет",
whose controls name three virtual light sources, periodically ignored taps
— no toggle, no glow — until its settings dialog was opened once with no
changes. "Periodically" was every fresh tab: the #337 lazy split left
_toggleIntent (and the confirm-line helpers) on the card as stubs
delegating into the editor runtime, so a plain View tap on a cold tab
threw `Houseplan editor runtime is not loaded` synchronously inside the
click handler. Opening any editor surface loaded the runtime and "healed"
the tab for its lifetime.
The View card now owns toggle resolution: _toggleIntent calls
resolveToggleIntent directly (device-toggle.ts was already in the initial
graph; the card owns _planHass/_fullRegistryHass/_virtualLights), and
_toggleStateText/_toggleConfirmationStateText/_toggleConfirmationLines
moved with it. The editor runtime delegates back to the host — one source
of truth, editor consumers (dialog preview, hint lines) unchanged.
Every product smoke preloads the runtime, so none of them could see this
class of regression. The new smoke_cold_view_toggle mirrors the field
config on a genuinely cold tab: a real switch drives three passive
virtual lamps with one tap, a controlled lamp drives its switch back,
tap_confirm renders its state lines and confirms, and the editor chunk is
never requested. A registry mutant restores the old delegation and is
killed by that smoke.
Issue: #357
User-Visible: yes
Declaring the whole matrix in --expect-change could accept a completely
foreign capture (different font stack, different machine): no undeclared
passed scenes would remain, and undeclared passed scenes are exactly what
proves the capture environment equals the accepted baseline's. The
realistic failure is fatigue, not malice — a mass framing change where the
author lists "everything that went red", accidentally sweeping in scenes
that diverged because of the environment.
Acceptance now requires a witness floor: after subtracting
--expect-change/--expect-new, at least min(10, 10% of baseline scenes)
undeclared scenes must match their accepted baselines BYTE-FOR-BYTE (a
sub-threshold 'passed' proves nothing about the environment — #351). A
truly total repaint passes only with an explicit
--no-witnesses --reason="…", and the reason is written into the baseline
manifest — a trace in the artifact and its git history, not just in the
shell history. A first-ever capture with no baselines requires no
witnesses: every frame there is declared in --expect-new anyway.
Issue: #355
User-Visible: no
The production LANGUAGE_RUNTIME was a handwritten twin of the tested
LanguageRuntime class (germanDictionary/Pending/Failed): equivalent on the
day it was written, invisible to every i18n-runtime test afterwards. The
registry now exports one page-scoped `new LanguageRuntime(LANGUAGE_REGISTRY,
…)` instance — the whole existing suite starts proving the object production
actually runs, and a contract unit (instanceof + source free of the old
field names) keeps the duplicate from returning.
The class gains an optional `loadFailed(code)` hook — fired once when a
dictionary load settles into English fallback — and the registry fans it out
through `subscribeLanguageLoadFailures`. Only the View card subscribes (it
alone owns toast infrastructure): a failed language pack now shows the new
`toast.locale_load_failed` message (en/ru/de) instead of a console-only
warning; space card and both GUI editors keep the console warning as before.
Proofs: contract unit, hook unit, subscription unit; smoke_german_locale
extended — the both-attempts-failed scenario now asserts the visible toast;
two new registry mutants (handwritten-twin returns, toast dropped).
Issue: #354
User-Visible: yes
Network failure of the editor runtime is no longer terminal: the loader
re-arms to idle and the next explicit press starts a fresh cycle, while a
fingerprint mismatch on either attempt stays terminal. The toast now says
what actually helps — retry advice for the network, refresh advice for a
foreign build — via one shared lazyLoadFailureMessage helper (new i18n key
editor.retry_advice in en/ru/de).
The field smoke caught a second, deeper bug on the way: Chromium records a
FAILED module in the page module map permanently, so retrying the same URL
(even the cache-busted one) never touched the network again. Every retry
now carries a per-cycle nonce and becomes a genuinely new module request.
A proxy-cached stale entry no longer kills the card silently: the entry
facade is rewritten at build time from a static re-export into a top-level
`try{await import(...)}catch{...}` — importers keep the happy-path
guarantee (await import(entry) still resolves only after
customElements.define), and the catch defines a fallback element with a
localized "reload the page" panel. Content-hashed chunks are served with
`public, max-age=31536000, immutable`, and verifyBundleTree now fails on
orphan chunks that the manifest does not name.
Proofs: loader units for re-arm/terminality/toast wording + an AST check
that both loaders forward the terminality flag; smoke_entry_stale (en/ru)
against a tree without the main chunk; smoke_lazy_editor_chunk extended —
second press after network failure now really opens the editor; pytest for
the immutable header; orphan-tree unit; five new registry mutants.
TESTING.md budget line updated to the #352 ceiling alongside.
Issue: #353
User-Visible: yes
Extend the existing localized dialog footer measurements to German at desktop and 320 px. The smoke now checks opening, physical-wall and space dialogs for containment, responsive wrapping and horizontal overflow, closing #348 review r1-M1.
Issue: #348
User-Visible: no
Add Deutsch across all card surfaces and backend flows, backed by the language registry introduced in #62. German loads as a fingerprint-checked page-shared locale chunk so EN/RU remain synchronous and the initial View budget stays intact. Root render gates prevent mixed-language flashes, retry once, and fail open to English. Extend parity, runtime, bundle, browser and visual coverage, plus contributor and user documentation.
Issue: #348
User-Visible: yes
Sergey Matyunin